Why does Nanny think its necessary for Janie to marry

Nanny decides that Janie’s sexual awakening could lead to her downfall, so she pressures her into marrying Logan Killicks, despite her original wish that Janie go to school and “pick from a higher bush and a sweeter berry.” Nanny is most concerned that Janie will be left financially destitute if she dies before Janie …

Why does Nanny want Janie married?

Nanny decides to get Janie married as quickly as possible; she wants to ensure that Janie is in a secure situation and will be taken care of when Nanny dies. When Janie rebels, Nanny reminds her of the hardships she and Janie’s mother both endured throughout their lives; Nanny only wants Janie to have a better life.

Who was nanny What did she try to teach Janie?

Nanny tells Janie she needs to marry quickly since “Ah can’t be always guidin’ yo’ feet from harm and danger.” Nanny wants Janie to live a financially secure life after her impending death. This desire is not only motivated by her concern for Janie, but by the worldview she developed from her experience in slavery.

What is Nanny's view of marriage?

Nanny thinks that marriage to a respected man who owns his own land will give this to Janie. Janie listens to her grandmother and marries a man by the name of Logan Killicks. In the end, Nanny’s dream of better things for Janie only ends up limiting her freedom.

How does Nanny view marriage in Their Eyes Were Watching God?

Nanny in Their Eyes Were Watching God | Shmoop.

How did Nanny help Janie?

A domestic servant who was born a slave, Nanny has raised and sheltered her granddaughter. When sixteen-year-old Janie begins to consider her own dreams and desires, Nanny interposes a different vision. She compels Janie to marry an older man, Logan Killicks, whose sixty acres and a mule constitute his eligibility.

Why does Nanny want Janie to marry Logan Killicks and how does Nanny explain this to Janie?

Nanny arranges Janie’s marriage to Logan because she values financial security and respectability over love. Logan pampers Janie for a year before he tries to make her help him with the farming work. Feeling used and unloved, Janie leaves him for Jody Starks.

Why do you think Janie and Nanny have different views on love?

Contrast Janie and Nanny’s views of love. … Nanny believes that a decent marriage where she can be provided for is better than a romantic marriage but Janie believes there needs to be romance.

How did Nanny raise Janie?

Nanny sees that Janie is being criticized by other black children for living with a white family and wearing white children’s hand-me-down clothes, so Nanny buys a house and land to raise Janie on. When Janie is 16 and kisses Johnny Taylor, Nanny calls her in for a talking-to.

How does Janie feel about Nanny?

As for her grandmother, Janie admits to herself that “she hated her grandmother and had hidden it from herself…. under a cloak of pity”(89). Janie had always felt sorry for her grandmother and pitied the life Nanny was forced to live, therefore she could not admit to being angry at Nanny for forcing her to marry.

Article first time published on

Why does Nanny scold Janie?

Nanny scolds Janie for being unappreciative that she married a man of great wealth and social status. Janie leaves and Nanny prays for God to care for Janie because she has done the best she could, a month later she dies.

Why is Nanny scared for Janie?

Why is Nanny scared for Janie? Janie is a woman now, and Nanny feels that Janie will be an easy target for any man who wants to take advantage of her.

What does she mean that Nanny loved to deal in scraps?

Janie comes to understand that her Nanny was imposing on her identity by “dealing in scraps” (89), but she is willing to go against her Nanny’s wishes to see ships in mud puddles (89). She salvages control of her life begins her road towards self discovery.

What advice does Nanny give to Janie about her marriage?

What is Nanny’s advice to Janie when she tells her how she feels? She tells her not to cry and to wait; her mind might change. Janie should give the marriage time and while doing so not to let Logan wait on her hand and foot.

What happened to Nanny shortly after Janie was married?

What happened to Nanny shortly after Janie was married? She died. … She discovered that marriage did not make love. Describe Joe Starks.

How does Nanny control power?

Nanny Crawford uses power to get Janie to obey her and marry Logan Killicks. Later, Logan Killicks exerts power over Janie as he is older and patriarch. Jody Starks also controls Janie through his patriarchal power. This leads to an unhappy marriage at home and final scolding to Starks by Janie on his deathbed.

What does Janie learn about love and marriage from her relationship with Logan?

She learned from her marriage to Logan Killicks that she could not learn to love someone. After her marriage to Jody Starks, Janie realized that equality is important within a marriage. … Janie learned through her three marriages even though she had bad experiences with love; there was a thing as true love.

What does Janie think will happen after she marries Logan Killicks?

What does Janie think will happen after she marries Logan Killicks? She will get pregnant.

How does Janie respond when nanny brings up the fact that Logan has land?

Nanny berates Janie for not appreciating Logan’s wealth and status. She sends Janie on her way, again telling her that, in time, she will develop feelings for Logan. After Janie leaves, Nanny prays to God to care for Janie, saying that she, Nanny, has done the best that she could.

Why does Nanny say she is a cracked plate What is Janie's response What does Nanny mean by this?

What does Nanny mean when she says that she is a “cracked plate”? She is an elderly women who has been through a great deal in her life. She needs to be handled kindly.

Who did Janie and Nanny live with when Janie was a little girl?

She and Nanny lived in a house on the property of Mrs. Washburn, Nanny’s very sympathetic and helpful white employer. Janie played with Mrs. Washburn’s white grandchildren, and it was not until she saw herself in a group picture, when she was six years old, that she discovered that she was not white.

Why does Janie agree to the marriage?

Janie’s first dream was dead, so she became a woman. When Janie was younger, her Nanny implied that with marriage, love would follow automatically. With this belief in mind, Janie agrees to marry Logan Killicks, a man she does not love.

How long after Janie seeks marriage advice from Nanny does she pass away?

Within a month, Nanny is dead. Janie hopes that her marriage to Logan Killicks will bring her love and happiness. As she says to her grandmother, “Ah wants to want him sometimes.” Janie’s and Nanny’s views of marriage clearly contrast with one another.

Who did Nanny have a baby with?

| The Nanny. Fran gives birth to twins! From Season 6 Episode 16, ‘The Finale: Part 2’.

What ideas does Janie have about love marriage?

What ideas does Janie have about love? She believed that being married will cause love. What does Janie believe will happen after she and Logan get married? She believes that once they are married that she will love him.

How is love defined within the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God?

By Zora Neale Hurston (Click the themes infographic to download.) In Their Eyes Were Watching God, idealized romantic love is the protagonist’s ultimate goal. … Her vision of true love is associated with innocence, openness, understanding, and equality between the lovers.

Who did Janie marry first?

Logan Killicks – Logan is Janie’s first husband, a product of an arranged marriage by Janie’s grandmother (Nanny). Logan seemed to be an excellent husband for Janie because he owned his own property and was well-known and respected throughout the community. Logan, however, treated Janie more as a slave than a wife and …

Does Janie find the love she desired?

Janie’s quest for love leads her along different paths. She gains strength from the protective love of Nanny and Logan as well as the possessive love of Joe. Janie finds her desired love with Tea Cake. … As a result of her lifelong encounters, Janie gains autonomy and learns the value of true love.

What does Nanny want Janie to do before she passes from old age?

Nanny catches Janie with Johnny and decides to marry Janie off to Logan Killicks, a wealthy middle-aged farmer. She wants to see Janie in a secure situation, which Logan Killicks can provide, before she dies. She says that Black women are the mules of the world and that she doesn’t want Janie to be a mule.

Who does Nanny want Janie to marry Why does she think this will be a good match why doesn't Janie agree?

Nanny wants Janie to marry Logan Killicks. Even though he is not the white man Nanny dreams of her having, he has a lot of money, owns a good amount of land, and wants to marry Janie. Janie doesn’t agree because she doesn’t love Logan. If she wants to marry anyone, it would be Johnny Taylor.

How old is Janie when Logan married?

Though Janie hopes that it will grow, there is never any gentleness or love between her and Logan. She is 15 or 16 years old when she is married off to Logan and later, she grows to resent her grandmother for selling her off, like a slave.