Who was Stein Why did Elie lie to him

Stein, Eliezer’s cousin by marriage, wants nothing more than news of his family. Eliezer lies to Stein, telling him that his wife (Reizel) and children are fine. Eliezer’s lie allows Stein to find the will to live; Stein has no desire to survive unless his family is well.

Why did Elie Wiesel lie to his relative Stein?

The reason Elie initially lied to Stein about the fate of his family was to give him hope and a reason to survive. Elie understands that without hope and something to live for, one can easily give up and die in the horrific environment.

What does Stein ask Elie?

According to him, Reizel’s aunt is the wife of Elie’s father. As for Elie himself, he recognizes Stein right away, as he had known Reizel before she left for Belgium. Stein’s purpose for looking for Elie’s father is to ask about the fate of his wife Reizel and two young sons.

Who is Stein of Antwerp in night?

Stein of Antwerp A shrunken, bespectacled fellow, Stein introduces himself to Elie’s father on the sixth day at Auschwitz. He asks for news of Reizel and their boys, who emigrated to Belgium. In exchange for Elie’s fabricated news, the exuberant Stein returns with half rations of bread.

How did Stein die in night?

There is never a clear answer on Stein’s fate. It is assumed that he died after learning of the truth fate of his family when a transport of prisoners…

Why does Elie lie to Stein about his family quizlet?

Eliezer lied in hopes that it would provide Stein with some hope and happiness, this quick decision was immoral. Eliezer’s decision to lie derived from his hope that it would make Stein feel better.

What lie does Elie tell to his relative Stein Why does Stein stop visiting Elie and his father?

Elie lied because he wanted Stein to have some hope of them surviving and so the German’s didn’t know about them. He stops seeing them because the German leader who was running it was replaced and he decides to take a transport to see Reizel and his two boys.

What did Elie lie about in night?

Elie lies about his age and occupation so that he goes to the labor camp rather than the crematorium. … Elie means that he will never be able to forget how differently he feels towards his faith now that he’s seen the cruelty that God has allowed upon such innocent creatures.

Why did Elie lie to Stein of Antwerp about hearing good news about his wife and children?

What is the best explanation for why Elie lied to Stein of Antwerp about hearing good news about his wife and children? To give the man some happiness. What was the name of the camp that Elie and his father arrived at during the beginning of chapter 4? Where are they first taken to work?

What did Elie tell a lie about?

Taking the prisoner’s advice, Eliezer lies about his age, telling Mengele he is eighteen. He also says that he is a farmer rather than a student, and is motioned to Mengele’s left, along with his father. Despite Eliezer’s joy at remaining with his father, uncertainty remains.

Article first time published on

Why did Stein stop seeing Elie?

Why does Stein stop coming to see Elie? – Steins stops coming to see Elie because he realized the real news, and that Elie lied to them, so he was in despair and lost hope, so he doesn’t go to see Elie and his father anymore.

What camp does Elie enter at the end of the chapter?

Eliezer can’t even feel his wounded foot. At last, they reach a camp, Gleiwitz, and they enter the barracks to sleep.

Who shows kindness to Eliezer after he is beaten by a kapo?

Who shows kindness to Elie after he is beaten by a Kapo? A young French girl.

Was Mrs Schachter crazy?

She is a middle-aged woman who goes crazy after she’s separated from her husband and packed into a cattle car headed to Auschwitz. Throughout the long nights in the train, she punctuates the imprisoned Jews’ journey with screaming and rambling about fire and flames, warning and begging the Jews to see the fire.

What happened to Elie's father?

His father died of starvation and dysentery in the Buchenwald camp.

Why does the Gypsy strike his father and how does he react explain what he means when he speaks of how much he's changed?

Why does the gypsy strike Wiesel’s father and how does Wiesel react when this happens? The Gypsy striked Wiesel’s father because he asked where the toilet was and Elie just sat there and watched while it happened. … Wiesel is referring to the words their new overseer said to them whenever they got to Auschwitz.

Why did Eliezer and his father lie to Dr Mengele?

Why did Eliezer and his father lie to Dr. Mengele about their ages? They gave an older and younger age, if you couldn’t work because you were to young or old you were sent to be killed.

Who is Eliezer separated from at the beginning of Chapter 3?

When chapter 3 of Night by Elie Weisel opens, Eliezer and his family have been forced from their homes in Sighet, Transylvania, and deported in cattle cars to Birkenau, a selection checkpoint for all Auschwitz newcomers. Here, he and his father are separated from his mother and sister.

What warning does Stein from Antwerp offer Eliezer and his father?

What advice does Stein from Antwerp give to Elie and his father? Avoid the selection. Eat when you can.

What is the real news Stein hears?

When Stein hears the real news about his wife and children, he does not return. We assume that he gave up hope and died. In the evenings, the men in Block 17 discuss their faith.

How does Elie respond when the gypsy struck his father why do you think Elie reacted this way?

Why? What was his father’s response? Elie did nothing, because as the gypsy struck his father Elie was in shock of what just happened. His father came back in line and guessed Elie’s feelings quietly saying “it doesn’t hurt.”

What was Elie told about the crematory night?

Q. What was Elie told about the crematory? That that’s where the food was cooked.

Who is IDEK night?

In Night, Idek is one of the Kapos and in charge of the narrator of the book, Eliezer. Idek is a prisoner in charge of a Kommando, or work squad, within the concentration camp. Eliezer falls victim to Idek’s fits of uncontrollable rage several times, and so does Eliezer’s father.

What did Stein want?

What did Stein want? He wanted to know if the Wiesels had any news of his own family.

Why does Eliezer lie and tell the SS that he is a farmer?

Why does Eliezer lie and tell the SS that he is a farmer, instead of admitting he is a student? He wants to work in the fields and not in the school. He wants them to know he shouldn’t be in the camp. He wants them to think he is strong and can do work.

What lies were Eliezer and his father told to tell the SS officers and why?

They must say that they are eighteen and forty. He gestures towards the chimney of the crematorium to show them their fate if they are rejected as unfit for labor. This is why Elie lies and says that he is eighteen years old when he is questioned by an SS officer (the notorious Dr. Mengele, as he later discovers).

What chapter did Elie lie about age?

In the third chapter of Night , Elie lied about his age and occupation when he was asked by the officer because those who were over the age of…

Who forces Elie to give up his gold crown?

Franek, the foreman, decides he wants Eliezer’s gold crown. Eliezer won’t give it to him. But, Franek discovers Eliezer’s weakness—his father. Franek begins to torment Eliezer’s father during their marches.

What is it that Elie's father keeps on begging for Elie is hesitant in getting him this?

Elie’s father keeps asking for water. He is crying and begging for water. A guard tells him to shut up but he doesn’t hear the guard. Again he begs for water, and the guard beats him.

Why didn't Wiesel join in the scramble for food?

Why didn’t Wiesel join in the scramble for food? … His father just wanted to rest, but Elie knew that was to die in the snow. What emotions did Wiesel experience as he watched his father die the last week?

What horrible thing does Elie witness a son Meir do to his father?

Don’t you recognize me?” His son continues beating him until he is dead and takes the bread from him. After killing his father and getting the bread, he is also attacked and killed for bread. You can read the exact details on page 68.